Here is a fic of what goes through Robin Hawke’s (same Hawke in my Lifeline fic) mind during “A New Path.” Isabela and Aveline are the unlucky two who get to go along on the field trip of doom.
Angst abounds.
“But…if things go wrong…if he possesses me, I need you to strike me down.”
“I’m sorry, what?” Robin asks. She can’t have heard Merrill right. She couldn’t just asked–
“If something goes wrong, you’ll have to kill me.”
Robin isn’t sure what hurts worse, hearing her lover ask her to end her life if she gets possessed or the way she says it as if it would be the easiest thing in the world. Robin crosses her arms so Merrill won’t see the way her hands have started trembling. She looks away for a moment and tries to will her throat to untighten.
How could she ask that? After seeing what happened to Robin when Leandra was killed. After sharing her bed for going on four years and knowing the dreams she still struggled with of losing her mother and Carver. After knowing the nightmares she had of things happening to Bethany in the Gallows. After all those nights of holding Robin when she sobbed…how could she ask this?
“So you’re…sure about risking becoming an abomination? Just for a chance to fix that spooky mirror of yours?” Robin’s voice is lower than usual from trying to keep the waver out. She wonders if Merrill notices.
“Ma vhenan, I have to do this. I owe it to my people to finish this.”
The determination is there, still. Robin looks away, clenching her jaw. She feels ill. But she was never very good at saying “no” to a pretty girl, much less to Merrill.
“You’re the only one I trust. Please, ma vhenan.”
That settles it. Robin, never much for prayer, sends a silent plea to Andraste that it won’t come to having Merrill’s blood on her hands.
“All right. I’ll go.”
———————-
On the path to the base of Sundermount, Robin walks several paces ahead, as usual, with Isabela at her side. But she still manages to hear Merrill conversing with Aveline. Merrill asks the guard captain to look for Hawke, and for Isabela. Robin has to suppress the sudden urge to run behind a rock and vomit. She hates this feeling. It’s too much like the way she felt years ago, running after blood trails in Lowtown looking for her mother.
She feels Isabela’s hand on her shoulder and she glances at her friend.
“You all right, Hawke? You look a bit green.” Isabela raises an eyebrow.
“I’m fine,” Robin replies, with a smile that falters just enough to make Isabela frown. “Just…if anything ever happens to me…keep an eye on Bethany, will you?”
Isabela frowns again and gives her a gentle shove. “Don’t talk like that. You’re Hawke. You fought the Arishok and all his guards. Nothing is going to happen to you.”
Robin manages a chuckle. “I didn’t do that alone, though.”
Isabela gives her another shove, and for just a moment, Robin doesn’t feel so scared.
————————
They reach the altar in the graveyard, and Merrill stops to pray. To the mother of the Creators, no less. Mythal, all mother. Robin’s facade cracks again.
“Would it help if I prayed, too?” she asks, hoping Aveline and Isabela will pass it off as cheek.
Merrill smiles, and Robin’s heart breaks a little more.
———————-
They reach the demon’s cave, but the demon isn’t there. Robin feels relieved. Until the Keeper shows up.
The Keeper let the demon possess her, so that it wouldn’t possesses Merrill. Robin can understand the desire to save Merrill. And she could almost kiss Marethari for it.
Until she asks Merrill to kill her, and Merrill refuses.
Robin wants to shake her, to ask her why, if she can’t bring herself to kill the Keeper when asked…then why in the name of the Maker and the Creators did she think Robin could kill her? She wants to scream and she wants to cry, but she’s a grown woman, and -damned- if she’ll let a demon see her cry.
They fight the demon. It calls up spirits of dead elves–the hunters killed by the varteral, Pol, others–and they call Merrill traitor, useless, a curse upon the clan. It makes Robin angry enough to shove aside her own feeling for a moment. Long enough to finish the fight.
And then Merrill does have to kill her Keeper. Out of the corner of her eye, Robin sees Aveline turn away when Merrill draws the knife.
Merrill is distraught, wishes she could wake up, and this all would just be a dream. Robin knows that feeling all too well. She doesn’t say a word, but she helps Merrill stand and leads them out of the cave.
—————-
The elves meet them, looking for the Keeper. More accusations against Merrill, and the word “monster.” Robin bristles. Merrill tells them the Keeper is dead and they blame her. Robin can’t stand it.
“Stand down, all of you.”
That’s clearly the worst thing Robin could have said.
—————
Robin feels even more ill when the fighting is done. The Dalish camp is littered with the bodies of Merrill’s people, the people she risked everything for. And all for what? There’s nothing left now. Except Merrill. Robin can’t help but be glad of that. Even if she’s afraid to look at her just yet.
She’s afraid she’ll break, or that Merrill will. If Merrill breaks, Robin will break. They’re both covered in blood, and Robin wonders if Merrill will ever forgive her for slaughtering her clan.
She wants a bath and enough alcohol to make things go black.
—————
“I thought I could help them. I wanted to save them. But they wouldn’t listen…”
Robin wraps her arms around Merrill, not knowing what else to do.
Merrill leans back against her. “I don’t know what to do now. You’re all I have left.”
“Stay with me,” Robin murmurs, nuzzling Merrill’s hair. “We’ll…muddle through somehow.” Merrill turns in her embrace and hides her face against Robin’s shoulder and cries. Robin strokes her hair and holds her close. Now they’re both broken, she thinks, but maybe the pieces will find a way of fitting back together better than they did before.